In 2011, 43-year-old Army veteran Edwin “Trey” Gennette lived just outside Pensacola, Florida, with a pet possum and a talking Ford Mustang. One warm June evening, he began poking around the “Casual Encounters” section of Craigslist, where he found an ad promising a novel erotic situation. “2 sisters seeking a man that handle both [of] us,” it said. “We are ready for a hot night, are you?” He was. But when he e-mailed the address in the ad, Gennette received a quick response from a woman named Amber, making clear that only one of the sisters was 19. “My lil sis is in town visiting me for the summer,” wrote Amber. “She is 14, you ok with that?” “Well I think she is a bit young, lol but depends on what you have in mind,” Gennette wrote back.

He sent Amber a photo of himself with his pet possum.

Amber sent back a photo showing two young women on a boat. Gennette and Amber chatted for a while over e-mail, sharing weekend plans. Gennette suggested the sisters come over to see the possum, which was recovering from veterinary surgery to her “female parts.” He offered to give the two girls a ride in his Mustang. 5     

Leave a Reply