FindTheBest CEO Kevin O’Connor and Director of Operations Danny Seigle. (credit:

The top US patent court has upheld an award of attorneys’ fees (PDF) against a patent troll that sued a startup called FindTheBest (now Graphiq) in 2013. The fee award against Lumen View Technology was the first one granted under new rules that came into effect as a result of the Supreme Court’s 2014 Octane Fitness decision.
The ruling by the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, published Friday, serves as a signpost as to what kind of fees will be upheld under the new standard. But, it’s not a complete win for Graphiq. While the three-judge appeals panel upheld the basis of the fee award, they vacated the award itself, which was a little more than $300,000. The panel’s opinion said that the lower court’s decision to double the requested fees wasn’t justified.
“It’s been a lengthy battle, but seeing the Federal Circuit explicitly inviting the District Court to award sanctions under Rule 11 is a great signal,” said Graphiq CEO Kevin O’Connor in an e-mailed comment to Ars. “We’re confident that a fair assessment of fees will occur back in the District Court. This is just one more step in our fight against Lumen View, and believe me, it’s nowhere near over.”
Read 10 remaining paragraphs | Comments

Leave a Reply